# Blocksmith Simplified V1 Design QA

## Evidence

- Welcome reference: `/workspace/scratch/7e50f8070af1/upload/image-edit-target-aff3b7271248cdaa.png`
- Main-interface reference: `/workspace/scratch/7e50f8070af1/upload/image-edit-target-f18f997b2597e257.png`
- Welcome side-by-side: `qa/compare-welcome.jpg` (reference left, implementation right)
- Main side-by-side: `qa/compare-main.jpg` (reference left, implementation right)
- Browser viewport: 1363 × 936 CSS pixels for the welcome; 1348 × 926 CSS pixels for the scrollable main document.

## Visual review

- The welcome uses the approved screen asset full-viewport. The comparison is pixel-faithful apart from browser JPEG compression and the visible test cursor.
- The workshop preserves the approved dark millinery-shop shell, brass command row, left controls, parchment crown preview, right specifications/community/tip column, stand button, and founder plaque.
- The central crown is intentionally live geometry rather than the static reference rendering. It changes with all three head shapes and all four approved crown families and shows the complete domed block.
- The Venmo asset uses a light-tan background and has no RH mark in the center.
- Opening, bridge, and pin-slack rows are absent.

## Issues found and resolved

- P1: the right tip jar and founder plaque extended below a common 936-pixel browser viewport. Compact desktop-height rules now keep the full task surface visible.
- P2: the parchment texture originally tiled into obvious rectangular bands. It now uses one softly blended cover texture.
- P2: the welcome image originally stretched slightly on a wider viewport. It now uses a centered cover crop matching the approved reference.
- Remaining P0/P1/P2 visual issues: none.

## Interaction and console review

- Welcome button gates the workshop successfully.
- Head shape, units, hat size, crown height, and all four profiles update the preview and specifications.
- Save Profile creates a local settings file.
- Generate STL creates a 5,614-triangle crown in the tested state.
- Help, optional fit-check download, and tip-jar dialogs open and close successfully.
- App-origin browser console errors: none. The cloud browser extension emitted unrelated metadata errors, which were excluded.

## Content dependency before public launch

The Reddit URL follows the requested `r/BlocksmithHatMakers` destination. The Facebook vanity URL is present but should be confirmed by Rich because private/new Facebook groups are not publicly indexable.

final result: passed
